Wednesday, 18 Nov 2026 Breaking: Assam Minister Pijush Hazarika visits Madhya Pradesh to study successful irrigation models
BREAKING: Apple launches AI platform | Tesla earnings beat estimates | Nvidia stock surges | Bitcoin crosses major resistance
National

Delhi High Court quashes defamation case against Pinaki Misra, says basic material missing

Delhi High Court quashes defamation case against Pinaki Misra, says basic material missing

New Delhi [India], August 27 (ANI): The Delhi High Court has quashed criminal defamation proceedings against senior advocate and former MP Pinaki Misra, holding that there was not enough material to prima facie show that the alleged remarks had lowered the complainant's reputation in the eyes of others.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma, in a judgment pronounced on August 25, set aside the summoning order issued against Misra and quashed the criminal proceedings arising from the complaint.
The case arose from a complaint filed by Siddhartha Singh, who alleged that Misra had made defamatory remarks against him in an interview published online. The alleged remarks included the words "crook" and "blackmailer". Singh claimed that the remarks damaged his reputation and affected his professional life. The trial court had summoned Misra under Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), finding sufficient grounds to proceed with the defamation case.
Misra challenged the summoning order before the High Court and denied giving the alleged interview. His counsel argued that Singh had examined only himself during the pre-summoning proceedings and had not produced any person who could show that the alleged remarks had actually lowered his reputation in the eyes of others.
The defence also pointed out that the reporter, author, editor or any other person connected with the online publication had not been examined to establish that Misra had actually made the alleged statements. The High Court took note of these submissions while examining whether there was sufficient material to continue the criminal case.
The High Court referred to Explanation 4 to Section 499 IPC, which requires that an alleged imputation must lower the moral or intellectual character, professional character or credit of a person in the estimation of others for it to amount to defamation.
Justice Sharma observed that Singh's own assertion that his reputation had been damaged was not, by itself, sufficient to establish this legal requirement. The court noted that there was no statement of any other person or other material on record to prima facie demonstrate that Singh's reputation had been lowered in the estimation of others.
The court also noted that Misra had specifically denied giving the alleged interview. He had subsequently written to the editor of another newspaper on March 22, 2019, denying that he had given the alleged interview and seeking publication of a clarification. Despite this, there was no independent material before the trial court connecting the alleged statements in the online report with Misra.
Justice Sharma made it clear that at the stage of taking cognizance or issuing summons, a court is not required to conduct a detailed trial or undertake a meticulous appreciation of evidence. However, the basic ingredients of the alleged offence must still be prima facie disclosed from the material placed before the court.
In the present case, the High Court found that the necessary foundational material was missing. The complainant had not produced evidence to show that the alleged remarks had lowered his reputation in the estimation of others, while the alleged interview itself had not been independently proved through the concerned reporter, author, editor or another person associated with the publication.
The High Court therefore held that allowing the criminal proceedings to continue would not serve the ends of justice and would instead subject Misra to the rigours of a criminal trial without sufficient foundational material.
Exercising its powers under Section 482 of the CrPC, the court quashed the April 20, 2019 summoning order and all consequential proceedings. The petition filed by Pinaki Misra was accordingly allowed. (ANI)

Tags

Related News

Assam Minister Pijush Hazarika visits Madhya Pradesh to study successful irrigation models
National
Assam Minister Pijush Hazarika visits Madhya Pradesh to study successful irrigation models

<p>Rajgarh (Madhya Pradesh) [India], November 18 (ANI): Assam Minister for Irrigation, Agriculture and Parliamentary Aff...

"Wait for 7 days": Abhishek Banerjee claims TMC symbol ownership, says it will "always" remain with Mamata Banerjee; vows upcoming revelations on affidavit row
National
"Wait for 7 days": Abhishek Banerjee claims TMC symbol ownership, says it will "always" remain with Mamata Banerjee; vows upcoming revelations on affidavit row

<p>Kolkata (West Bengal) [India], November 18 (ANI): Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Abhishek Banerjee launched a sharp poli...

NEET UG Paper leak case: Confidential material procured, distributed, exploited; accused were part of unbroken chain of conspiracy, says court
National
NEET UG Paper leak case: Confidential material procured, distributed, exploited; accused were part of unbroken chain of conspiracy, says court

<p>New Delhi [India], November 18 (ANI): Special Fast Track Court on Wednesday directed the framing of charges against 1...

"INDIA Alliance defeated BJP in 2024" alleges SP chief Akhilesh Yadav, targets BJP ahead of 2027 Assembly Polls
National
"INDIA Alliance defeated BJP in 2024" alleges SP chief Akhilesh Yadav, targets BJP ahead of 2027 Assembly Polls

<p>Gorakhpur (Uttar Pradesh) [India], November 18 (ANI): Samajwadi Party (SP) chief Akhilesh Yadav on Wednesday claimed...

“Wahi khaliq, wahi malik”: SP leader Azam Khan returns home to Rampur after release on interim bail
National
“Wahi khaliq, wahi malik”: SP leader Azam Khan returns home to Rampur after release on interim bail

<p>Rampur (Uttar Pradesh) [India], November 18 (ANI): Samajwadi Party (SP) leader Azam Khan returned to his residence in...

Rahul Gandhi's remark at Columbia University sparks row; BJP calls him "India's Mir Jafar"; Congress says Govt worried about facts coming to light
National
Rahul Gandhi's remark at Columbia University sparks row; BJP calls him "India's Mir Jafar"; Congress says Govt worried about facts coming to light

<p>New Delhi [India], November 18 (ANI): Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi's remarks at Columbia Univer...